‘It’s the only thing I can do:’ Illinois mother continues annual fight to keep son’s killer in prison

DANVILLE, Ill. — It’s become a yearly routine that Katherine Lee simply doesn’t like.

Yet more than 40 years after her son’s murder, she thinks “it’s the only thing I can do for him.”

Lee is again circulating a petition on behalf of her son, David Grinestaff, against the parole of James Dumas, who killed her teenage boy during a gas station robbery in 1975. It’s the 22nd time she has petitioned against Dumas’ parole. His hearing is set for July 20.

“I just don’t like doing it all the time,” Lee told the Danville, Illinois Commercial-News. She added it’s stressful for many others in town, and they share her disbelief when each parole hearing comes up once again.

In July of last year, Dumas’ parole was denied for the minimum of one year. Per state statute, the Illinois Prisoner Review Board can opt to deny parole for one, two or three years.

Lee thinks it’s “ridiculous” she has to petition against his parole so often. She also said that everybody is behind her, supporting her efforts to keep Dumas behind bars.

To Lee, it’s important that her son’s killer serves a full sentence. In 1976, Dumas was sentenced to 100-150 years in prison.

In August of 1975 Dumas, then 32, entered a gas station on the east side of Danville with another man, robbed Grinestaff of $25 and shot him. He has never named the other person involved.

At the time of the murder, Dumas had been on parole for months on a conviction from Indiana. After his 14th parole hearing, Dumas finally admitted to the murder, although he claimed it was an accident.

“It didn’t accidentally go off,” Lee said in March of last year. “He was shot from about 18 inches inches away.”

Lee has distributed petitions against Dumas’ parole at various restaurants in Danville. An online petition is also available.

Denison writes for the Danville, Illinois Commercial-News.

Local News

Lake Oconee Elks Lodge 2849 hosts luncheon at the Georgia War Veterans Home

Columns

TONI SAYS: Medicare rules worry HR manager

Columns

PATHWAYS TO HEALING: Bee pollen

Local News

LOA recognized as Math and Literacy Leader School

Local News

100+ Who Care Dell Webb Lake Oconee donates to Neighbors Helping Neighbors

Local News

Freedom Riders scholarship

Local News

Rotary Week 5 raffle winner

Local News

Rotary Club honors February 2025 Students-of-the-Month

Columns

PATHWAYS TO HEALING:

Local News

OPAS Lounge Series delivers unforgettable night of music and celebration

Local News

LOA art and literary students attend exclusive performance at Steffen Thomas Museum of Art

Local News

Lake Oconee Botox welcomes Evans

Local News

The Vining Group welcomes Pickren to growing team

Local News

National Home Watch Association announces 3rd annual National Home Watch Month

Local News

Athens Physical Therapy Firefly Trail Ticket to Ride bike event returns March 22 linking Athens and Union Point

Local News

Madison-Morgan Cultural Center presents Antique and Design Show

Local News

Piedmont Athens Regional and Akins Ford partner to enhance breast health services

Local News

Johnson named Sales Executive of the Month for January

Local News

Tickets on sale this week for Lake Country Players’ latest production

Local News

Friday, March 14 Breeze will be delayed

Local News

Greene Chamber welcomes Lake Country Books and Gifts

Local News

Zeb Hartline named director of Culinary Operations for Reynolds Lake Oconee

Local News

Second Harvest food distribution March 15

Local News

Brooke Adams joins Coldwell Banker Lake Oconee Realty/Lake Country