Congressional Democrats to file emoluments lawsuit against Trump

WASHINGTON – Nearly 200 Democratic members of Congress agreed to file a lawsuit Wednesday against President Donald Trump alleging that by retaining interests in a global business empire he has violated constitutional restrictions on taking gifts and benefits from foreign leaders.

The lead senator filing the complaint in federal district court, Sen. Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., said Tuesday that the lawsuit has already drawn more congressional plaintiffs – 196 – than any legal action previously taken against a president. No Republicans have yet joined in the lawsuit, although they will be invited to do so, Blumenthal said.

An advance copy of the legal complaint reviewed by The Washington Post argues that those in Congress have special standing because the Constitution’s “foreign emoluments clause” requires the president to obtain “the consent of Congress” before accepting any gifts.

The legal effort, led in the House by Rep. John Conyers Jr., D-Mich., is likely to escalate tensions between the White House and Capitol Hill, where at least five committees are investigating various issues related to the Trump administration.

News of the lawsuit emerged less than 24 hours after attorneys general in the District and Maryland, both Democrats, filed suit alleging that payments to Trump violated the Constitution’s anti-corruption clauses. In another lawsuit filed against Trump by business competitors, the Justice Department recently defended Trump’s actions, arguing that he violated no restrictions by accepting fair-market payments for services.

Legal scholars consulted by the congressional plaintiffs said their complaint is distinctive because of the special standing granted to Congress.

“The framers of our Constitution gave members of Congress the responsibility to protect our democracy from foreign corruption by determining which benefits the president can and cannot receive from a foreign state,” said Erwin Chemerinsky, the incoming dean of the law school at the University of California at Berkeley.

“When the president refuses to reveal which benefits he is receiving – much less obtain congressional consent before accepting them – he robs these members of their ability to perform their constitutional role,” Chemerinsky said. “Congressional lawmakers . . . have a duty to preserve the constitutional order in the only way they can: by asking the courts to make the President obey the law.”

Other legal scholars were skeptical, particularly since the lawsuit was filed only by Democrats, the minority party in both houses of Congress.

“Just because they can’t convince their peers doesn’t mean you can go to court to get what you want,” said Andy Grewal, a law professor at the University of Iowa.

Generally, a lawmaker can sue if he or she has suffered individual injury, Grewal said. In addition, Congress can sue as a body, as has happened in the past, such as with the lawsuit challenging President Barack Obama’s health-care overhaul.

But a case like this is problematic, he said.

“Because this is individual legislators who don’t have any individual injuries, it will be hard for them to get standing,” he said.

However, Norman Eisen, who served as a co-counsel in the other two emoluments-clause lawsuits, said he thought “the congressional plaintiffs in this case do have proper” standing to sue. He pointed out that in the lawsuit filed on behalf of Trump competitors, the Justice Department argued that Congress had special capacity to deal with questions related to emoluments.

The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment Tuesday night, but on Monday, press secretary Sean Spicer dismissed the lawsuit filed by the two state attorneys general, saying it’s “not hard to conclude that partisan politics may be one of the motivations.”

The 37-page congressional complaint contends that the nation’s founders were concerned that foreign powers could interfere with American affairs. The suit says that the founders were particularly worried that “foreign states would give benefits and rewards to the nation’s chief executive to subvert his loyalty.”

As a result, they wrote the emoluments clause of the Constitution with language “both sweeping and unqualified,” the lawmakers’ lawsuit says.

The obscure clause in Article I of the Constitution says: “[N]o Person holding any Office of Profit or Trust under [the United States], shall, without the Consent of the Congress, accept of any present, Emolument, Office, or Title, of any kind whatever, from any King, Prince, or foreign State.” The language is interpreted as prohibiting any officeholder – including the president – from accepting a gift, payment or other benefit from a foreign state without the consent of Congress.

A memo prepared by the Senate plaintiff states that “these benefits include any compensation for services rendered in a private capacity such as when a foreign government throws a party at a hotel owned by a federal official.”

Although the emoluments clause has a complex history, the request by the lawmakers is rather simple. It asks the court to enjoin the president from “accepting any benefits from foreign states without first obtaining Congressional consent.”

Local News

Jennifer Vaughan Ansley Real Estate, Christie’s International sponsors 2025 Heart and Soul Gala

Local News

CGTC EAGLE delegate named regional finalist

Local News

Second Harvest February food distribution Feb. 15

Local News

GWM 4th Annual Writers Retreat next month

Local News

TONI SAYS: The difference between long- and short-term care plans

Local News

BBB: How to recognize phony debt collection calls and texts 

Local News

Monthly real estate market update for Lake Oconee area – January 2025

Columns

Columns

ON THE MARKET: Complacency

Local News

Putnam native, aspiring Broadway director takes on first with ‘The Color Purple’ production

Local News

Rotary Week 51 raffle winner

Local News

Rotary Week 50 raffle winner

Local News

Piedmont Athens Regional Beautiful You Boutique receives reaccreditation

Local News

Greene Chamber of Commerce welcomes Jessi Lynch

Local News

Outdoor Innovations of Georgia joins as sponsor for the 2025 Heart and Soul Gala

Local News

BBB offers tips on choosing a tax preparer

News

Rotary Club announces Greene County STAR student

Local News

Rotary Week 49 raffle winner

Local News

Rotary Week 48 raffle

Local News

Rotary Club honors January 2025 Students-of-the-Month

Columns

PATHWAYS TO HEALING: Brain health

Local News

PAPA announces ‘On Golden Pond’ auditions

Local News

Our Father’s Kitchen: Serving the Community with Love and Nourishment every Saturday

Local News

OPAS celebrates thrilling fall season and announces exciting Mardi Gras event